Significant Decline
Pastoral Vacancies
Conflict & Crisis
Why is This Important?
Between 70-90% of our CRBA churches are either plateaued or in decline and find themselves needing assistance. Our mission is to assist these churches with the goal of bringing back life and health for Gospel impact.
Every Church is unique and requires a specialized approach to addressing congregational and community needs with a focus on bringing health and vitality to the body.
Below is a preview of a brand-new resource we are developing for our CRBA churches:
Our journey alongside our churches begins with the pastor. We want to meet you where you are, hear how God is leading you, and discuss how we can join you in seeking a new day. Our journey of revitalization always includes and supports the pastor.
This is where the renovation analogy becomes valuable. Before renovating a house, you need to know what is sound, what is damaged, and what needs attention. But you don’t demolish the foundation simply because the paint is peeling.
In our first month of partnering with the local church, we discuss practical strategies.
Practical strategies: Review five years of worship attendance, baptisms, giving, and ministry participation. Walk the property as a first-time guest. Conduct a simple congregational health survey. Listen to longtime members about the church’s history, strengths, disappointments, and hopes.
Ask not only “What is broken?” but also “What has God preserved here that we can build upon?”
In our third month of working together…before discussing programs, budgets, or organizational charts, we want to help the church revisit its biblical purpose. A church can become so consumed with maintaining its activities and property that it gradually loses sight of the people it is called to reach and disciple.
Practical strategies: Lead a congregational listening and vision gathering. Celebrate the church’s history without treating its past as the blueprint for its future. Revisit worship, discipleship, fellowship, evangelism, and missions. Ask members to identify who in their community is currently being overlooked.
In this fourth month of our journey, this is likely one of the fastest and most encouraging months because meaningful improvements can often be made without a major financial investment.
The guiding question: If a family visited our church for the first time this Sunday, would they know where to go, what to do, and whether they were welcome?
Practical strategies: Conduct a guest-experience walkthrough; evaluate entrance, parking, nursery, children’s spaces, restrooms, and sanctuary directions. Identify two or three naturally welcoming people to serve as hosts. Develop a simple guest follow-up process. Remove clutter and outdated announcements.
A church may have loving people, faithful preaching, and meaningful ministries, but the community cannot respond to an invitation it never receives—or cannot find.
Practical strategies: Establish or update the church’s Google Business Profile, Facebook page, and a simple mobile-friendly web presence. Verify that service times, address, phone number, and ministry information are accurate and consistent. Develop a basic weekly announcement schedule. Place current photos of the church building and entrances online.
Recruit one person to own communication and one backup. The goal is not to create more channels than volunteers can maintain.
This month focuses on equipping and enlisting new volunteers and leaders. In struggling churches, leadership that does not rotate or recruit new leadership often is to blame. This is an opportunity for the church to tear down walls of leadership and involvement of new people.
Practical strategies: Map existing committees and ministry roles. Identify positions without clear responsibilities, succession plans, or rotation. Invite existing leaders to mentor emerging workers. Introduce role descriptions and reasonable terms where appropriate. Examine whether church governance unintentionally discourages participation.
Revitalization cannot stop with improving the church’s internal health. The church must begin looking outward again.
Practical strategies: Walk or drive through the surrounding community. Identify changes in demographics and neighborhood needs. Speak with school leaders, neighbors, and local ministry partners. Encourage members to pray for and build relationships with people outside the congregation.
Choose one sustainable community engagement initiative—not an elaborate event that exhausts everyone and disappears after a weekend.
Month eight is not graduation from revitalization. It is the transition from an initial process to a sustainable pattern of renewal.
Practical strategies: Revisit the original Church Health Snapshot. Celebrate measurable changes and meaningful stories. Identify unfinished work without discouragement. Review the pastor’s health and volunteer workload. Establish a simple 90-day action plan and quarterly association check-ins.
First tangible win: A congregation can identify specific evidence of greater health, clear next steps, and people responsible for carrying those steps forward.
Examination
Listen and learn about the church. Get facts and data by visiting with Pastors, leaders, and church members Conduct one on one and group interviews. Contact and visit with both current and past leadership.
Identify issues currently present in the life of the Church.
Obtain Church History and Conduct Health Assessment (10 yrs of ACP and other tools as needed)
A Church Profile/Portfolio is prepared and produced.
Evaluation
Evaluate the Health and Spiritual condition of the Pastor and leaders of the church.
Conduct a change readiness inventory on the church Site Visit Assessment.
Meet with an identified group of congregational leaders to discuss findings.
Recommendations are drafted and prepared for the larger body to review.
Presentation
Facts and Evaluation Findings will be presented to the Church in stages
Decision Makers/Key Stakeholders and leaders of the congregation will have the opportunity to view the findings and dialogue with the presenters.
A formal presentation will be made to the larger congregation.
Recommendation
Recommendations are developed and shared with church leaders, and the leadership team and formal recommendations are drafted for Church affirmation.
A formal decision timeline is established for the Church to affirm recommendations.
Affirmation
Church votes to accept or reject the CRT/Leadership Team Recommendations.
Per a Positive Vote, the Change Process/Recommendations commence.
Upon rejection of recommendations, CRT/CRBA withdraws Coaching. The consultant provides support as resources are requested and time allows.
Change Formulation
Solemn Assembly: Call for repentance of both past and present issues of the church.
Work on an exit strategy for Pastor/Staff if needed.
Place Transitional Pastor in leadership.
New Interim Governance Decision Making Team in place.
Form a larger team of congregational influencers/CR team to work with Coach and rePlanting, Transitional Pastor.
Develop ministry partnerships with established healthy churches for support and resourcing.
Implementation
Address the following: Church Structure and systems, programming, facilities, communication, and church documents/governance issues.
Transition Team begins meeting regularly per the plan agreement with Pastor, CR Coach, and DOM. Recommendation/Plan agreements are implemented, monitored, and adjusted as necessary.
Regular Member’s Meetings are held for prayer, progress reports, and feedback.
Multiplication
At years 3-5 and upon satisfactory progress according to plan, this Church contributes its story and its Congregations’ resources to the larger work of Church Congregation/rePlanting.
The congregation sponsors a fully assessed rePlanter and Congregation.
While time frames are unique to each congregation, the development of plans and progress toward identified initiatives follow this process. The following have been shown to be true:
• The longer the term of decline and the greater the average tenure of existing members, the greater the time required for renewal.
• The more acute the crisis, the more vigorous the action steps are required to address and arrest the declining condition of the Church.
• Outside leadership, resources, and new members and attendees are required and necessary to truly create a new culture and positive change.
• Existing Staff, Leaders, and Stakeholders must relinquish directional decision making.
